Category: Legal Issues

09/16/2011 11:55:39 AMWhat Constitutes a "copy" of software under copyright law?

Software auditors almost always try to find ways to maximize the number of allegedly infringing software "copies" at issue in an audit engagement. It is typical for the Business Software Alliance (BSA), the Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA), and...

Read more


05/05/2011 11:52:15 AMObtaining Payment Terms for BSA Settlement

Negotiating a settlement with the Business Software Alliance ("BSA") to resolve a copyright infringement dispute over allegedly unlicensed software can be arduous and costly. The BSA typically demands a penalty based on some multiple of the MSRP of each product...

Read more


09/24/2010 11:02:58 AMWhen to Buy vs. Uninstall in Software Audits

One of the most common mistakes I encounter in software audits is what I call the post-effective date software buying spree. The buying spree occurs in response to a letter from a publisher or publisher's attorneys requesting a self audit....

Read more


09/13/2010 09:45:57 AMLicense Ambiguities in Software Audits

Without a contractual provision to the contrary, ambiguous terms in a software license will be construed against the software publisher. Provided that there are no other business factors that would make litigation unwise, an ambiguous license agreement is the situation...

Read more


05/13/2010 09:39:01 AMLitigating Copyright Infringement Claims Related To Competing Software Applications

Software copyright infringement litigation (sometimes called software anti-piracy claims) comes in an array of varieties. Frequently, it is functionally indistinguishable from disputes involving literary or audio-visual works and centers on claims that an infringer copied a copyright owner's work and...

Read more


05/13/2010 09:37:30 AMAdopting Software Use Policies to Protect Against Copyright Infringement Claims

The Business Software Alliance ("BSA"), and the Software & Information Industry Association ("SIIA") pursue copyright infringement claims on behalf of software publishers, such as Microsoft, Adobe, and Autodesk, among many others. Typically the BSA and SIIA send audit letters to...

Read more


04/13/2010 09:34:52 AMJudge Rejects Copyright Damages Compilation Components

In Nature's Enterprises, Inc. v. Pearson (2010), the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York rejected Nature's Enterprises ("NEI's") request for damages for each component part of a compilation. NEI had alleged that Pearson infringed ten of...

Read more


03/13/2010 09:31:56 AMWhat is the BSA's Definition of Software Piracy?

"Software piracy" is a favorite catch-phrase used by the Business Software Alliance (BSA) and the software companies it represents. Most people understand software piracy to involve the intentional copying and, in many cases, distribution of copyrighted software to third parties...

Read more


03/13/2010 09:13:15 AMBSA Pursues Software Audits Despite Questionable Information from Informants

The Business Software Alliance (BSA) regularly targets small-to-medium sized businesses for expensive software audits to determine whether those businesses are in compliance with their BSA-member software licenses. In furtherance of that effort, the BSA offers cash rewards to disgruntled current...

Read more


04/13/2009 08:53:17 AMSuing the Informant in BSA Audits

The targets of BSA audits frequently believe that they know who reported them to the Business Software Alliance. Justifiably angry, they want to know what legal recourse they have against the informant. Because the informants are frequently out of work,...

Read more


04/07/2009 12:40:27 PMUnbundling Software Suites in BSA Audits

One of the most controversial tactics the BSA uses when calculating its settlement demands is its practice of unbundling software suites such as Microsoft Office and Adobe Creative Suite. Unbundling occurs when the target of a BSA audit is unable...

Read more


07/13/2007 08:55:20 AMBusiness Software Alliance to Reward Individuals Up To $1 Million for Qualified Reports of Copyright Infringement

Last week, the Business Software Alliance (BSA) announced that it will temporarily increase its rewards incentive from $200,000 to $1 million from July to October 2007. This is the second dramatic increase in the organization's rewards program which offers financial...

Read more


04/05/2007 08:47:55 AMA New Definition of Software Piracy

A New Definition of Software Piracy What is software piracy? Like many politically charged phrases, the definition of software piracy is influenced by your financial interests and your viewpoint. The Business Software Alliance defines software piracy as: "The illegal use...

Read more